Wine critics use different rating systems to evaluate wines, helping wine-lovers make informed buying decisions. The most common scales are the 100-point scale and the 5-star scale.

The 100-Point Scale:

The 100-point scale is a precise and widely accepted method for rating wines, primarily used by influential critics such as Robert Parker, Tim Atkin, and James Suckling. Here's a breakdown of what each range typically signifies:

  • 95-100 Points (Classic/Exceptional): Wines in this range are of extraordinary quality, showcasing exceptional complexity, character, and aging potential. They are often considered the best wines of their type and vintage.
  • 90-94 Points (Outstanding): Wines rated in this range are of superior quality, offering a high level of finesse and flavor. They are excellent examples of their style and are highly recommended.
  • 85-89 Points (Very Good): These wines are solid and well-made, with good balance and flavor. They represent good quality and are enjoyable to drink.
  • 80-84 Points (Good): Wines in this category are enjoyable but may lack some depth or complexity. They are good everyday drinking wines.
  • 75-79 Points (Average): These wines are drinkable but may have minor flaws or lack distinct character.
  • 50-74 Points (Below Average to Poor): Wines in this range are often flawed or unbalanced, and are generally not recommended.

The 5-Star Scale:

The 5-star scale is a simpler and more intuitive method for rating wines, commonly used by critics such as John Platter. Here's what each star rating typically means:

  • 5 Stars (Outstanding): Wines with a 5-star rating are exceptional, displaying remarkable quality, complexity, and depth. They are considered top-tier and highly desirable.
  • 4 Stars (Very Good): These wines are of high quality, offering well-balanced flavors and good complexity. They are excellent choices and often represent good value.
  • 3 Stars (Good): Wines in this range are solid and reliable, with enjoyable flavors and balance. They are good everyday drinking wines.
  • 2 Stars (Fair): These wines are drinkable but may have minor flaws or lack significant character. They are acceptable but not particularly noteworthy.
  • 1 Star (Poor): Wines with a 1-star rating are often flawed or unbalanced, and are generally not recommended.

 

THE CRITICS

Robert Parker (RP): Robert Parker, an American wine critic, is one of the most influential figures in the wine industry. Introduced through his publication, The Wine Advocate, his 100-point scale revolutionized wine ratings in the US. Wines scoring between 90-100 points are considered outstanding, while those between 80-89 are very good.

Tim Atkin (TA): Tim Atkin is a renowned British Master of Wine and journalist. He rates wines using the 100-point scale, and his comprehensive reports on regions like Bordeaux, Burgundy, and South Africa are highly respected. His evaluations provide detailed insights, reflecting his extensive expertise and passion for wine.

John Platter (JP): John Platter is a notable South African wine critic who popularized the 5-star rating system through his annual Platter's South African Wine Guide. Wines rated 5 stars are deemed extraordinary and worth seeking out, making his guide a trusted resource for wine enthusiasts.

James Suckling (JS): James Suckling, an American critic with significant influence in Europe, uses the 100-point scale. He previously worked with Wine Spectator and now runs his own platform. Suckling's ratings are highly regarded for their focus on both established and emerging wine regions.

James Halliday (JH): James Halliday is a celebrated Australian wine critic, is widely recognized for his expertise in Australian wines. He uses a 100-point scale to score wines and publishes his reviews in the annual Halliday Wine Companion. Wines scoring above 95 points are considered outstanding examples of their style, and his reviews are a definitive resource for those exploring Australian wine regions.


AWARDS & ACCOLADES

 

Wine Enthusiast (WE): Wine Enthusiast is a prominent US-based wine publication known for its detailed wine reviews and lifestyle content. It uses the 100-point scale to rate wines, with scores above 90 points highlighting wines of exceptional quality. Their reviews are written by a team of experienced tasters who specialize in various regions, making Wine Enthusiast a trusted guide for wine lovers.

Wine Spectator (WS): Wine Spectator, based in the US, is one of the most influential wine publications in the world. It employs the 100-point scale to evaluate wines, focusing on flavor, balance, and overall quality. Wines scoring 90 points or higher are considered outstanding. The magazine also provides insights into wine culture and lifestyle, appealing to both casual and serious enthusiasts.

Decanter Awards (DA): The Decanter Awards, or Decanter World Wine Awards, is organized annually by the UK-based Decanter magazine, and is among the world's most prestigious wine competitions. Wines are rated on the 100-point scale by a panel of expert judges, providing a comprehensive assessment of quality and value.

The Trophy Wine Show (TS): The Trophy Wine Show is one of South Africa's most prestigious wine competitions, known for its rigorous judging process and high standards. Founded in 2002, the show brings together a panel of local and international wine experts to evaluate wines across various categories, using the 100-point scale to rate entries.

Winemag (WM): Winemag.co.za is an online magazine celebrating South Africa's best wines, and providing a forum for fine wine discussions. Each year they release a Prescient Cape Bordeaux Blend Report - A prestigious list highlighting and ranking the top South African red wines made in the Bordeaux style. All wines are blind tasted, meaning the panel does not know which producer made the wines while evaluating them. This makes the Prescient Report one of the most respected accolades for red blends in South Africa.

Gilbert & Gaillard International Challenge (GG): The Gilbert & Gaillard International Challenge is a renowned global wine competition organized by the esteemed Gilbert & Gaillard Wine Guide. It celebrates exceptional wines through a meticulous blind-tasting process conducted by expert judges, ensuring fairness and quality in evaluation. Open to winemakers and distributors worldwide, the competition welcomes a variety of wine styles, including red, white, rosé, sparkling, and dessert wines.

Falstaff (FA): Falstaff is a renowned Austrian wine and lifestyle publication which evaluates and score wines with precision and expertise, using the 100-point scale. Some tastings are conducted blind, others are open, but all are done by their expert editorial team, specializing in a range of popular wine regions across the world.

Jancis Robinson (JR): Jancis Robinson, OBE, is a respected British wine critic, journalist and wine writer. A Master of Wine, and advisor to the wine cellar of the late Queen Elizabeth II, Jancis is one of the world's most influential wine critics, providing reliable and expert recommendations for wines from both the old and new worlds.

 
Understanding these ratings helps consumers navigate the complex world of wine, ensuring they choose wines that align with their preferences and expectations.


For personal recommendations or guidance from our expert sommeliers, contact us on +1 888 812 2543

!